---
title: Your Church May Switch Health Insurance. Five Questions to Ask.
description: Your church is considering a new insurance provider. Here are five things to ask before the decision is made.
image: https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hubfs/Health%20Insurance%20feature%20image.jpg
---

[2024 Renewal Information](http://reformedbenefits.org/open-enrollment)

[![Rba](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/ReformedBenefits_July2024/images/Logo-color.png?width=516&name=Logo-color.png "Rba")](https://reformedbenefits.org/)

[![Rba](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/ReformedBenefits_July2024/images/Logo-white.png?width=840&name=Logo-white.png "Rba")](https://reformedbenefits.org/)

[Get Started](http://reformedbenefits.org/ready-to-join/)

[Login](https://secure.bswift.com/default.aspx?abbrev=reformedbenefits)

*Menu*

- [Get Started](http://reformedbenefits.org/ready-to-join/)
- [Login](https://secure.bswift.com/default.aspx?abbrev=reformedbenefits)

- [About](https://reformedbenefits.org/about/)
- [FAQs](https://reformedbenefits.org/faq/)
- [Open Enrollment Information](https://reformedbenefits.org/open-enrollment-information/)
- [Advantages of RBA](https://reformedbenefits.org/advantages-of-rba/)
- [Benefit Solutions](https://reformedbenefits.org/benefit-solutions/)
- [Resources](https://reformedbenefits.org/member-resources/)
- [Blog](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/)
- [Contact](https://reformedbenefits.org/contact/)

# Your Church May Switch Health Insurance. Five Questions to Ask.

By

[Sarah Hull](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/author/sarah-hull)

The letter arrives, or the news comes up in a staff meeting: your church is considering a switch to a new health insurance provider. Nothing’s decided yet, but it’s worth knowing what’s actually on the table before it happens.

Whenever a provider change occurs, it’s unlikely your benefits stay exactly the same. A doctor or specialist you’ve been seeing may turn out to be out-of-network under a new carrier. That’s something you need to know before you need an appointment, not during one.

When no one asks, it’s easy to assume a new plan works like the old one. That’s why these aren’t things to find out after the switch happens. They’re what you should be asking while it’s still being decided and when you might be able to affect the choices made. 

Here are the five things you should ask while your church is still weighing the decision.

## Five Questions That Help Avoid Surprises

Switching providers is not an easy decision for churches. It’s usually a long process due to the complexity of the decision. Once you know which providers are being considered, ask these five questions.

### 1. Will my doctor still be in-network?

After a provider change is the worst time to find out if your doctor, any specialists, and your preferred hospital are still in-network. Don’t assume yes just because your current providers are in-network now.

### 2. Are my prescriptions on the formulary?

Every plan has a [formulary,](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/healthcare-insurance-terminology-simple-your-healthcare-insurance-glossary) which is the list of drugs it covers and what you’ll pay for each. A different carrier may have a different list. A medication that cost you thirty dollars last month could cost two hundred with the new provider.

Ask for a look at the formulary for all the candidates. If a drug’s cost does jump, there [may be other options](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/goodrx-or-insurance-why-you-should-shop-around-for-medications) before you assume you are stuck paying it.

### 3. Do I have a new ID card and portal login?

A new carrier means a new card, a new member portal, and new account details wherever your premium or copays get billed.

Ask what the onboarding process looks like: how fast you’ll get a card, how you’ll access the portal. This is especially important if you’re in the middle of treatment.

### 4. Does my plan structure match what I expected?

A new carrier can mean a new deductible, new copays, or a different HSA or FSA setup, even if the plan is described as “comparable” to your old one.

Get the actual plan documents, not just a summary. This is the best way to plan for changes and uncover major differences.

### 5. Do my pending referrals and pre-authorizations carry over?

If you have a referral or a pre-authorization in progress, don’t assume it will be transferred automatically. Different carriers handle this differently, and some require you to start over.

## What’s next

Most churches have a very small staff. If you find that the answers to your five questions are concerning, that is an insight your decision makers should be aware of.

If you’re the one deciding whether to switch, or whether your current plan is still the right fit, take [RBA’s Church Health Insurance Assessment.](https://reformedbenefits.org/5-questions-to-ask/) This short scorecard will look at how your plan stacks up. It’s built for exactly this decision.

- <https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/how-to-add-a-newborn-to-your-insurance-a-guide-for-ministry-families>
  
  ### Next Post How to Add a Newborn to Your Insurance: A Guide for Ministry Families

<http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/your-church-may-switch-health-insurance.-five-questions-to-ask> <https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/your-church-may-switch-health-insurance.-five-questions-to-ask&text=Your%20Church%20May%20Switch%20Health%20Insurance.%20Five%20Questions%20to%20Ask.> <http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/your-church-may-switch-health-insurance.-five-questions-to-ask> <https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/your-church-may-switch-health-insurance.-five-questions-to-ask>

[Toll Free: 800.701.8992](tel:8007018992) [benefits@reformedbenefits.org](mailto:benefits@reformedbenefits.org)

©Reformed Benefits Association

[![crafted-by-tbx-grey](https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hs-fs/hubfs/ReformedBenefits_July2024/Images/crafted-by-tbx-grey.png?width=131&name=crafted-by-tbx-grey.png "crafted-by-tbx-grey")](https://wearetbx.com/)

- [legal](http://reformedbenefits.org/legal/)
- [faq](http://reformedbenefits.org/?page_id=303)
- [privacy policy](http://reformedbenefits.org/privacy-policy/)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Sarah Hull",
    "url" : "https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/author/sarah-hull"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-16T14:52:58.190Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-16T14:52:58.000Z",
  "headline" : "Your Church May Switch Health Insurance. Five Questions to Ask.",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hubfs/Health%20Insurance%20feature%20image.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/your-church-may-switch-health-insurance.-five-questions-to-ask",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.reformedbenefits.org/hubfs/RBA-logo-1200x572.png"
    }
  }
}
```